Hello,
I am modelling a guyed mast.
Unfortunately, I am not convienced that member forces are accurate, since I have a similar old project (performed in other software) in which forces are twice as mine!
Here is my Staad file, as well as input for Staad editor.
STAAD SPACE
START JOB INFORMATION
ENGINEER DATE 30-Jan-20
END JOB INFORMATION
SET NL 80
INPUT WIDTH 79
UNIT METER KN
JOINT COORDINATES
1 -26.1973 2.8e-015 15.125; 2 -0.450013 19 0.259815; 3 -0.450013 38 0.259815;
4 -38.9711 4.1e-015 22.5; 5 -0.450013 60.8 0.259815; 6 -0.450013 79.8 0.259815;
7 -47.6314 5.1e-015 27.5; 8 -0.450013 100.8 0.259815;
9 26.1973 2.8e-015 15.125; 10 0.450013 19 0.259815; 11 0.450013 38 0.259815;
12 38.9711 4.1e-015 22.5; 13 0.450013 60.8 0.259815; 14 0.450013 79.8 0.259815;
15 47.6314 5.1e-015 27.5; 16 0.450013 100.8 0.259815;
17 2.13e-014 -5.6e-015 -30.25; 18 4e-016 19 -0.51963; 19 4e-016 38 -0.51963;
20 2.84e-014 -8.3e-015 -45; 21 4e-016 60.8 -0.51963; 22 3e-016 79.8 -0.51963;
23 4.62e-014 -1.01e-014 -55; 24 3e-016 100.8 -0.51963;
25 -0.450013 0.1 0.259815; 26 0.450013 1 0.259815; 27 0.450013 0.1 0.259815;
28 0 1 -0.51963; 29 1e-016 0.1 -0.51963; 30 -0.450013 1 0.259815;
31 0.450013 1.9 0.259815; 32 0 1.9 -0.51963; 33 -0.450013 1.9 0.259815;
34 0.450013 2.8 0.259815; 35 0 2.8 -0.51963; 36 -0.450013 2.8 0.259815;
37 0.450013 3.7 0.259815; 38 0 3.7 -0.51963; 39 -0.450013 3.7 0.259815;
40 0 3.8 -0.51963; 41 0 -1e-016 -0.51963; 42 -0.450013 3.8 0.259815;
43 -0.450013 1e-016 0.259815; 44 0.450013 3.8 0.259815;
45 0.450013 1e-016 0.259815; 46 -0.450013 3.9 0.259815;
47 0.450013 4.8 0.259815; 48 0.450013 3.9 0.259815; 49 0 4.8 -0.51963;
50 1e-016 3.9 -0.51963; 51 -0.450013 4.8 0.259815; 52 0.450013 5.7 0.259815;
53 0 5.7 -0.51963; 54 -0.450013 5.7 0.259815; 55 0.450013 6.6 0.259815;
56 0 6.6 -0.51963; 57 -0.450013 6.6 0.259815; 58 0.450013 7.5 0.259815;
59 0 7.5 -0.51963; 60 -0.450013 7.5 0.259815; 61 0 7.6 -0.51963;
62 -0.450013 7.6 0.259815; 63 0.450013 7.6 0.259815; 64 -0.450013 7.7 0.259815;
65 0.450013 8.6 0.259815; 66 0.450013 7.7 0.259815; 67 0 8.6 -0.51963;
68 1e-016 7.7 -0.51963; 69 -0.450013 8.6 0.259815; 70 0.450013 9.5 0.259815;
71 0 9.5 -0.51963; 72 -0.450013 9.5 0.259815; 73 0.450013 10.4 0.259815;
74 0 10.4 -0.51963; 75 -0.450013 10.4 0.259815; 76 0.450013 11.3 0.259815;
77 0 11.3 -0.51963; 78 -0.450013 11.3 0.259815; 79 0 11.4 -0.51963;
80 -0.450013 11.4 0.259815; 81 0.450013 11.4 0.259815;
82 -0.450013 11.5 0.259815; 83 0.450013 12.4 0.259815;
84 0.450013 11.5 0.259815; 85 0 12.4 -0.51963; 86 1e-016 11.5 -0.51963;
87 -0.450013 12.4 0.259815; 88 0.450013 13.3 0.259815; 89 0 13.3 -0.51963;
90 -0.450013 13.3 0.259815; 91 0.450013 14.2 0.259815; 92 0 14.2 -0.51963;
93 -0.450013 14.2 0.259815; 94 0.450013 15.1 0.259815; 95 0 15.1 -0.51963;
96 -0.450013 15.1 0.259815; 97 0 15.2 -0.51963; 98 -0.450013 15.2 0.259815;
99 0.450013 15.2 0.259815; 100 -0.450013 15.3 0.259815;
101 0.450013 16.2 0.259815; 102 0.450013 15.3 0.259815; 103 0 16.2 -0.51963;
104 1e-016 15.3 -0.51963; 105 -0.450013 16.2 0.259815;
106 0.450013 17.1 0.259815; 107 0 17.1 -0.51963; 108 -0.450013 17.1 0.259815;
109 0.450013 18 0.259815; 110 0 18 -0.51963; 111 -0.450013 18 0.259815;
112 0.450013 18.9 0.259815; 113 0 18.9 -0.51963; 114 -0.450013 18.9 0.259815;
115 -0.450013 19.1 0.259815; 116 0.450013 20 0.259815;
117 0.450013 19.1 0.259815; 118 0 20 -0.51963; 119 1e-016 19.1 -0.51963;
120 -0.450013 20 0.259815; 121 0.450013 20.9 0.259815; 122 0 20.9 -0.51963;
123 -0.450013 20.9 0.259815; 124 0.450013 21.8 0.259815; 125 0 21.8 -0.51963;
126 -0.450013 21.8 0.259815; 127 0.450013 22.7 0.259815; 128 0 22.7 -0.51963;
129 -0.450013 22.7 0.259815; 130 0 22.8 -0.51963; 131 -0.450013 22.8 0.259815;
132 0.450013 22.8 0.259815; 133 -0.450013 22.9 0.259815;
134 0.450013 23.8 0.259815; 135 0.450013 22.9 0.259815; 136 0 23.8 -0.51963;
137 1e-016 22.9 -0.51963; 138 -0.450013 23.8 0.259815;
139 0.450013 24.7 0.259815; 140 0 24.7 -0.51963; 141 -0.450013 24.7 0.259815;
142 0.450013 25.6 0.259815; 143 0 25.6 -0.51963; 144 -0.450013 25.6 0.259815;
145 0.450013 26.5 0.259815; 146 0 26.5 -0.51963; 147 -0.450013 26.5 0.259815;
148 0 26.6 -0.51963; 149 -0.450013 26.6 0.259815; 150 0.450013 26.6 0.259815;
151 -0.450013 26.7 0.259815; 152 0.450013 27.6 0.259815;
153 0.450013 26.7 0.259815; 154 0 27.6 -0.51963; 155 1e-016 26.7 -0.51963;
156 -0.450013 27.6 0.259815; 157 0.450013 28.5 0.259815; 158 0 28.5 -0.51963;
159 -0.450013 28.5 0.259815; 160 0.450013 29.4 0.259815; 161 0 29.4 -0.51963;
162 -0.450013 29.4 0.259815; 163 0.450013 30.3 0.259815; 164 0 30.3 -0.51963;
165 -0.450013 30.3 0.259815; 166 0 30.4 -0.51963; 167 -0.450013 30.4 0.259815;
168 0.450013 30.4 0.259815; 169 -0.450013 30.5 0.259815;
170 0.450013 31.4 0.259815; 171 0.450013 30.5 0.259815; 172 0 31.4 -0.51963;
173 1e-016 30.5 -0.51963; 174 -0.450013 31.4 0.259815;
175 0.450013 32.3 0.259815; 176 0 32.3 -0.51963; 177 -0.450013 32.3 0.259815;
178 0.450013 33.2 0.259815; 179 0 33.2 -0.51963; 180 -0.450013 33.2 0.259815;
181 0.450013 34.1 0.259815; 182 0 34.1 -0.51963; 183 -0.450013 34.1 0.259815;
184 0 34.2 -0.51963; 185 -0.450013 34.2 0.259815; 186 0.450013 34.2 0.259815;
187 -0.450013 34.3 0.259815; 188 0.450013 35.2 0.259815;
189 0.450013 34.3 0.259815; 190 0 35.2 -0.51963; 191 1e-016 34.3 -0.51963;
192 -0.450013 35.2 0.259815; 193 0.450013 36.1 0.259815; 194 0 36.1 -0.51963;
195 -0.450013 36.1 0.259815; 196 0.450013 37 0.259815; 197 0 37 -0.51963;
198 -0.450013 37 0.259815; 199 0.450013 37.9 0.259815; 200 0 37.9 -0.51963;
201 -0.450013 37.9 0.259815; 202 -0.450013 38.1 0.259815;
203 0.450013 39 0.259815; 204 0.450013 38.1 0.259815; 205 0 39 -0.51963;
206 1e-016 38.1 -0.51963; 207 -0.450013 39 0.259815;
208 0.450013 39.9 0.259815; 209 0 39.9 -0.51963; 210 -0.450013 39.9 0.259815;
211 0.450013 40.8 0.259815; 212 0 40.8 -0.51963; 213 -0.450013 40.8 0.259815;
214 0.450013 41.7 0.259815; 215 0 41.7 -0.51963; 216 -0.450013 41.7 0.259815;
217 0 41.8 -0.51963; 218 -0.450013 41.8 0.259815; 219 0.450013 41.8 0.259815;
220 -0.450013 41.9 0.259815; 221 0.450013 42.8 0.259815;
222 0.450013 41.9 0.259815; 223 0 42.8 -0.51963; 224 1e-016 41.9 -0.51963;
225 -0.450013 42.8 0.259815; 226 0.450013 43.7 0.259815; 227 0 43.7 -0.51963;
228 -0.450013 43.7 0.259815; 229 0.450013 44.6 0.259815; 230 0 44.6 -0.51963;
231 -0.450013 44.6 0.259815; 232 0.450013 45.5 0.259815; 233 0 45.5 -0.51963;
234 -0.450013 45.5 0.259815; 235 0 45.6 -0.51963; 236 -0.450013 45.6 0.259815;
237 0.450013 45.6 0.259815; 238 -0.450013 45.7 0.259815;
239 0.450013 46.6 0.259815; 240 0.450013 45.7 0.259815; 241 0 46.6 -0.51963;
242 1e-016 45.7 -0.51963; 243 -0.450013 46.6 0.259815;
244 0.450013 47.5 0.259815; 245 0 47.5 -0.51963; 246 -0.450013 47.5 0.259815;
247 0.450013 48.4 0.259815; 248 0 48.4 -0.51963; 249 -0.450013 48.4 0.259815;
250 0.450013 49.3 0.259815; 251 0 49.3 -0.51963; 252 -0.450013 49.3 0.259815;
253 0 49.4 -0.51963; 254 -0.450013 49.4 0.259815; 255 0.450013 49.4 0.259815;
256 -0.450013 49.5 0.259815; 257 0.450013 50.4 0.259815;
258 0.450013 49.5 0.259815; 259 0 50.4 -0.51963; 260 1e-016 49.5 -0.51963;
261 -0.450013 50.4 0.259815; 262 0.450013 51.3 0.259815; 263 0 51.3 -0.51963;
264 -0.450013 51.3 0.259815; 265 0.450013 52.2 0.259815; 266 0 52.2 -0.51963;
267 -0.450013 52.2 0.259815; 268 0.450013 53.1 0.259815; 269 0 53.1 -0.51963;
270 -0.450013 53.1 0.259815; 271 0 53.2 -0.51963; 272 -0.450013 53.2 0.259815;
273 0.450013 53.2 0.259815; 274 -0.450013 53.3 0.259815;
275 0.450013 54.2 0.259815; 276 0.450013 53.3 0.259815; 277 0 54.2 -0.51963;
278 1e-016 53.3 -0.51963; 279 -0.450013 54.2 0.259815;
280 0.450013 55.1 0.259815; 281 0 55.1 -0.51963; 282 -0.450013 55.1 0.259815;
283 0.450013 56 0.259815; 284 0 56 -0.51963; 285 -0.450013 56 0.259815;
286 0.450013 56.9 0.259815; 287 0 56.9 -0.51963; 288 -0.450013 56.9 0.259815;
289 0 57 -0.51963; 290 -0.450013 57 0.259815; 291 0.450013 57 0.259815;
292 -0.450013 57.1 0.259815; 293 0.450013 58 0.259815;
294 0.450013 57.1 0.259815; 295 0 58 -0.51963; 296 1e-016 57.1 -0.51963;
297 -0.450013 58 0.259815; 298 0.450013 58.9 0.259815; 299 0 58.9 -0.51963;
300 -0.450013 58.9 0.259815; 301 0.450013 59.8 0.259815; 302 0 59.8 -0.51963;
303 -0.450013 59.8 0.259815; 304 0.450013 60.7 0.259815; 305 0 60.7 -0.51963;
306 -0.450013 60.7 0.259815; 307 -0.450013 60.9 0.259815;
308 0.450013 61.8 0.259815; 309 0.450013 60.9 0.259815;
310 1.6e-015 61.8 -0.51963; 311 1.7e-015 60.9 -0.51963;
312 -0.450013 61.8 0.259815; 313 0.450013 62.7 0.259815;
314 1.6e-015 62.7 -0.51963; 315 -0.450013 62.7 0.259815;
316 0.450013 63.6 0.259815; 317 1.6e-015 63.6 -0.51963;
318 -0.450013 63.6 0.259815; 319 0.450013 64.5 0.259815;
320 1.6e-015 64.5 -0.51963; 321 -0.450013 64.5 0.259815;
322 1.6e-015 64.6 -0.51963; 323 -0.450013 64.6 0.259815;
324 0.450013 64.6 0.259815; 325 -0.450013 64.7 0.259815;
326 0.450013 65.6 0.259815; 327 0.450013 64.7 0.259815;
328 1.6e-015 65.6 -0.51963; 329 1.7e-015 64.7 -0.51963;
330 -0.450013 65.6 0.259815; 331 0.450013 66.5 0.259815;
332 1.6e-015 66.5 -0.51963; 333 -0.450013 66.5 0.259815;
334 0.450013 67.4 0.259815; 335 1.6e-015 67.4 -0.51963;
336 -0.450013 67.4 0.259815; 337 0.450013 68.3 0.259815;
338 1.6e-015 68.3 -0.51963; 339 -0.450013 68.3 0.259815;
340 1.6e-015 68.4 -0.51963; 341 -0.450013 68.4 0.259815;
342 0.450013 68.4 0.259815; 343 -0.450013 68.5 0.259815;
344 0.450013 69.4 0.259815; 345 0.450013 68.5 0.259815;
346 1.6e-015 69.4 -0.51963; 347 1.7e-015 68.5 -0.51963;
348 -0.450013 69.4 0.259815; 349 0.450013 70.3 0.259815;
350 1.6e-015 70.3 -0.51963; 351 -0.450013 70.3 0.259815;
352 0.450013 71.2 0.259815; 353 1.6e-015 71.2 -0.51963;
354 -0.450013 71.2 0.259815; 355 0.450013 72.1 0.259815;
356 1.6e-015 72.1 -0.51963; 357 -0.450013 72.1 0.259815;
358 1.6e-015 72.2 -0.51963; 359 -0.450013 72.2 0.259815;
360 0.450013 72.2 0.259815; 361 -0.450013 72.3 0.259815;
362 0.450013 73.2 0.259815; 363 0.450013 72.3 0.259815;
364 1.6e-015 73.2 -0.51963; 365 1.7e-015 72.3 -0.51963;
366 -0.450013 73.2 0.259815; 367 0.450013 74.1 0.259815;
368 1.6e-015 74.1 -0.51963; 369 -0.450013 74.1 0.259815;
370 0.450013 75 0.259815; 371 1.6e-015 75 -0.51963; 372 -0.450013 75 0.259815;
373 0.450013 75.9 0.259815; 374 1.6e-015 75.9 -0.51963;
375 -0.450013 75.9 0.259815; 376 1.6e-015 76 -0.51963;
377 -0.450013 76 0.259815; 378 0.450013 76 0.259815;
379 -0.450013 76.1 0.259815; 380 0.450013 77 0.259815;
381 0.450013 76.1 0.259815; 382 1.6e-015 77 -0.51963;
383 1.7e-015 76.1 -0.51963; 384 -0.450013 77 0.259815;
385 0.450013 77.9 0.259815; 386 1.6e-015 77.9 -0.51963;
387 -0.450013 77.9 0.259815; 388 0.450013 78.8 0.259815;
389 1.6e-015 78.8 -0.51963; 390 -0.450013 78.8 0.259815;
391 0.450013 79.7 0.259815; 392 1.6e-015 79.7 -0.51963;
393 -0.450013 79.7 0.259815; 394 -0.450013 79.9 0.259815;
395 0.450013 80.8 0.259815; 396 0.450013 79.9 0.259815;
397 1.6e-015 80.8 -0.51963; 398 1.7e-015 79.9 -0.51963;
399 -0.450013 80.8 0.259815; 400 0.450013 81.7 0.259815;
401 1.6e-015 81.7 -0.51963; 402 -0.450013 81.7 0.259815;
403 0.450013 82.6 0.259815; 404 1.6e-015 82.6 -0.51963;
405 -0.450013 82.6 0.259815; 406 0.450013 83.5 0.259815;
407 1.6e-015 83.5 -0.51963; 408 -0.450013 83.5 0.259815;
409 1.6e-015 83.6 -0.51963; 410 -0.450013 83.6 0.259815;
411 0.450013 83.6 0.259815; 412 -0.450013 83.7 0.259815;
413 0.450013 84.6 0.259815; 414 0.450013 83.7 0.259815;
415 1.6e-015 84.6 -0.51963; 416 1.7e-015 83.7 -0.51963;
417 -0.450013 84.6 0.259815; 418 0.450013 85.5 0.259815;
419 1.6e-015 85.5 -0.51963; 420 -0.450013 85.5 0.259815;
421 0.450013 86.4 0.259815; 422 1.6e-015 86.4 -0.51963;
423 -0.450013 86.4 0.259815; 424 0.450013 87.3 0.259815;
425 1.6e-015 87.3 -0.51963; 426 -0.450013 87.3 0.259815;
427 1.6e-015 87.4 -0.51963; 428 -0.450013 87.4 0.259815;
429 0.450013 87.4 0.259815; 430 -0.450013 87.5 0.259815;
431 0.450013 88.4 0.259815; 432 0.450013 87.5 0.259815;
433 1.6e-015 88.4 -0.51963; 434 1.7e-015 87.5 -0.51963;
435 -0.450013 88.4 0.259815; 436 0.450013 89.3 0.259815;
437 1.6e-015 89.3 -0.51963; 438 -0.450013 89.3 0.259815;
439 0.450013 90.2 0.259815; 440 1.6e-015 90.2 -0.51963;
441 -0.450013 90.2 0.259815; 442 0.450013 91.1 0.259815;
443 1.6e-015 91.1 -0.51963; 444 -0.450013 91.1 0.259815;
445 1.6e-015 91.2 -0.51963; 446 -0.450013 91.2 0.259815;
447 0.450013 91.2 0.259815; 448 -0.450013 91.3 0.259815;
449 0.450013 92.2 0.259815; 450 0.450013 91.3 0.259815;
451 1.6e-015 92.2 -0.51963; 452 1.7e-015 91.3 -0.51963;
453 -0.450013 92.2 0.259815; 454 0.450013 93.1 0.259815;
455 1.6e-015 93.1 -0.51963; 456 -0.450013 93.1 0.259815;
457 0.450013 94 0.259815; 458 1.6e-015 94 -0.51963; 459 -0.450013 94 0.259815;
460 0.450013 94.9 0.259815; 461 1.6e-015 94.9 -0.51963;
462 -0.450013 94.9 0.259815; 463 1.6e-015 95 -0.51963;
464 -0.450013 95 0.259815; 465 0.450013 95 0.259815;
466 -0.450013 95.1 0.259815; 467 0.450013 96 0.259815;
468 0.450013 95.1 0.259815; 469 1.6e-015 96 -0.51963;
470 1.7e-015 95.1 -0.51963; 471 -0.450013 96 0.259815;
472 0.450013 96.9 0.259815; 473 1.6e-015 96.9 -0.51963;
474 -0.450013 96.9 0.259815; 475 0.450013 97.8 0.259815;
476 1.6e-015 97.8 -0.51963; 477 -0.450013 97.8 0.259815;
478 0.450013 98.7 0.259815; 479 1.6e-015 98.7 -0.51963;
480 -0.450013 98.7 0.259815; 481 1.6e-015 98.8 -0.51963;
482 -0.450013 98.8 0.259815; 483 0.450013 98.8 0.259815;
484 -0.450013 98.9 0.259815; 485 0.450013 99.8 0.259815;
486 0.450013 98.9 0.259815; 487 1.7e-015 99.8 -0.51963;
488 1.7e-015 98.9 -0.51963; 489 -0.450013 99.8 0.259815;
490 0.450013 100.7 0.259815; 491 1.7e-015 100.7 -0.51963;
492 -0.450013 100.7 0.259815;
MEMBER INCIDENCES
1 1 2; 2 1 3; 3 4 5; 4 4 6; 5 7 8; 6 9 10; 7 9 11; 8 12 13; 9 12 14; 10 15 16;
11 17 18; 12 17 19; 13 20 21; 14 20 22; 15 23 24; 16 25 26; 17 27 28; 18 29 30;
19 28 31; 20 30 32; 21 26 33; 22 33 34; 23 31 35; 24 32 36; 25 35 37; 26 36 38;
27 34 39; 28 25 27; 29 27 29; 30 25 29; 31 30 28; 32 30 26; 33 26 28; 34 33 32;
35 33 31; 36 31 32; 37 36 35; 38 36 34; 39 34 35; 40 39 38; 41 39 37; 42 37 38;
43 38 40; 44 38 35; 45 35 32; 46 32 28; 47 28 29; 48 29 41; 49 39 42; 50 39 36;
51 36 33; 52 33 30; 53 30 25; 54 25 43; 55 37 44; 56 37 34; 57 34 31; 58 31 26;
59 26 27; 60 27 45; 61 46 47; 62 48 49; 63 50 51; 64 49 52; 65 51 53; 66 47 54;
67 54 55; 68 52 56; 69 53 57; 70 56 58; 71 57 59; 72 55 60; 73 46 48; 74 48 50;
75 46 50; 76 51 49; 77 51 47; 78 47 49; 79 54 53; 80 54 52; 81 52 53; 82 57 56;
83 57 55; 84 55 56; 85 60 59; 86 60 58; 87 58 59; 88 59 61; 89 59 56; 90 56 53;
91 53 49; 92 49 50; 93 50 40; 94 60 62; 95 60 57; 96 57 54; 97 54 51; 98 51 46;
99 46 42; 100 58 63; 101 58 55; 102 55 52; 103 52 47; 104 47 48; 105 48 44;
106 64 65; 107 66 67; 108 68 69; 109 67 70; 110 69 71; 111 65 72; 112 72 73;
113 70 74; 114 71 75; 115 74 76; 116 75 77; 117 73 78; 118 64 66; 119 66 68;
120 64 68; 121 69 67; 122 69 65; 123 65 67; 124 72 71; 125 72 70; 126 70 71;
127 75 74; 128 75 73; 129 73 74; 130 78 77; 131 78 76; 132 76 77; 133 77 79;
134 77 74; 135 74 71; 136 71 67; 137 67 68; 138 68 61; 139 78 80; 140 78 75;
141 75 72; 142 72 69; 143 69 64; 144 64 62; 145 76 81; 146 76 73; 147 73 70;
148 70 65; 149 65 66; 150 66 63; 151 82 83; 152 84 85; 153 86 87; 154 85 88;
155 87 89; 156 83 90; 157 90 91; 158 88 92; 159 89 93; 160 92 94; 161 93 95;
162 91 96; 163 82 84; 164 84 86; 165 82 86; 166 87 85; 167 87 83; 168 83 85;
169 90 89; 170 90 88; 171 88 89; 172 93 92; 173 93 91; 174 91 92; 175 96 95;
176 96 94; 177 94 95; 178 95 97; 179 95 92; 180 92 89; 181 89 85; 182 85 86;
183 86 79; 184 96 98; 185 96 93; 186 93 90; 187 90 87; 188 87 82; 189 82 80;
190 94 99; 191 94 91; 192 91 88; 193 88 83; 194 83 84; 195 84 81; 196 100 101;
197 102 103; 198 104 105; 199 103 106; 200 105 107; 201 101 108; 202 108 109;
203 106 110; 204 107 111; 205 110 112; 206 111 113; 207 109 114; 208 100 102;
209 102 104; 210 100 104; 211 105 103; 212 105 101; 213 101 103; 214 108 107;
215 108 106; 216 106 107; 217 111 110; 218 111 109; 219 109 110; 220 114 113;
221 114 112; 222 112 113; 223 113 18; 224 113 110; 225 110 107; 226 107 103;
227 103 104; 228 104 97; 229 114 2; 230 114 111; 231 111 108; 232 108 105;
233 105 100; 234 100 98; 235 112 10; 236 112 109; 237 109 106; 238 106 101;
239 101 102; 240 102 99; 241 115 116; 242 117 118; 243 119 120; 244 118 121;
245 120 122; 246 116 123; 247 123 124; 248 121 125; 249 122 126; 250 125 127;
251 126 128; 252 124 129; 253 115 117; 254 117 119; 255 115 119; 256 120 118;
257 120 116; 258 116 118; 259 123 122; 260 123 121; 261 121 122; 262 126 125;
263 126 124; 264 124 125; 265 129 128; 266 129 127; 267 127 128; 268 128 130;
269 128 125; 270 125 122; 271 122 118; 272 118 119; 273 119 18; 274 129 131;
275 129 126; 276 126 123; 277 123 120; 278 120 115; 279 115 2; 280 127 132;
281 127 124; 282 124 121; 283 121 116; 284 116 117; 285 117 10; 286 133 134;
287 135 136; 288 137 138; 289 136 139; 290 138 140; 291 134 141; 292 141 142;
293 139 143; 294 140 144; 295 143 145; 296 144 146; 297 142 147; 298 133 135;
299 135 137; 300 133 137; 301 138 136; 302 138 134; 303 134 136; 304 141 140;
305 141 139; 306 139 140; 307 144 143; 308 144 142; 309 142 143; 310 147 146;
311 147 145; 312 145 146; 313 146 148; 314 146 143; 315 143 140; 316 140 136;
317 136 137; 318 137 130; 319 147 149; 320 147 144; 321 144 141; 322 141 138;
323 138 133; 324 133 131; 325 145 150; 326 145 142; 327 142 139; 328 139 134;
329 134 135; 330 135 132; 331 151 152; 332 153 154; 333 155 156; 334 154 157;
335 156 158; 336 152 159; 337 159 160; 338 157 161; 339 158 162; 340 161 163;
341 162 164; 342 160 165; 343 151 153; 344 153 155; 345 151 155; 346 156 154;
347 156 152; 348 152 154; 349 159 158; 350 159 157; 351 157 158; 352 162 161;
353 162 160; 354 160 161; 355 165 164; 356 165 163; 357 163 164; 358 164 166;
359 164 161; 360 161 158; 361 158 154; 362 154 155; 363 155 148; 364 165 167;
365 165 162; 366 162 159; 367 159 156; 368 156 151; 369 151 149; 370 163 168;
371 163 160; 372 160 157; 373 157 152; 374 152 153; 375 153 150; 376 169 170;
377 171 172; 378 173 174; 379 172 175; 380 174 176; 381 170 177; 382 177 178;
383 175 179; 384 176 180; 385 179 181; 386 180 182; 387 178 183; 388 169 171;
389 171 173; 390 169 173; 391 174 172; 392 174 170; 393 170 172; 394 177 176;
395 177 175; 396 175 176; 397 180 179; 398 180 178; 399 178 179; 400 183 182;
401 183 181; 402 181 182; 403 182 184; 404 182 179; 405 179 176; 406 176 172;
407 172 173; 408 173 166; 409 183 185; 410 183 180; 411 180 177; 412 177 174;
413 174 169; 414 169 167; 415 181 186; 416 181 178; 417 178 175; 418 175 170;
419 170 171; 420 171 168; 421 187 188; 422 189 190; 423 191 192; 424 190 193;
425 192 194; 426 188 195; 427 195 196; 428 193 197; 429 194 198; 430 197 199;
431 198 200; 432 196 201; 433 187 189; 434 189 191; 435 187 191; 436 192 190;
437 192 188; 438 188 190; 439 195 194; 440 195 193; 441 193 194; 442 198 197;
443 198 196; 444 196 197; 445 201 200; 446 201 199; 447 199 200; 448 200 19;
449 200 197; 450 197 194; 451 194 190; 452 190 191; 453 191 184; 454 201 3;
455 201 198; 456 198 195; 457 195 192; 458 192 187; 459 187 185; 460 199 11;
461 199 196; 462 196 193; 463 193 188; 464 188 189; 465 189 186; 466 202 203;
467 204 205; 468 206 207; 469 205 208; 470 207 209; 471 203 210; 472 210 211;
473 208 212; 474 209 213; 475 212 214; 476 213 215; 477 211 216; 478 202 204;
479 204 206; 480 202 206; 481 207 205; 482 207 203; 483 203 205; 484 210 209;
485 210 208; 486 208 209; 487 213 212; 488 213 211; 489 211 212; 490 216 215;
491 216 214; 492 214 215; 493 215 217; 494 215 212; 495 212 209; 496 209 205;
497 205 206; 498 206 19; 499 216 218; 500 216 213; 501 213 210; 502 210 207;
503 207 202; 504 202 3; 505 214 219; 506 214 211; 507 211 208; 508 208 203;
509 203 204; 510 204 11; 511 220 221; 512 222 223; 513 224 225; 514 223 226;
515 225 227; 516 221 228; 517 228 229; 518 226 230; 519 227 231; 520 230 232;
521 231 233; 522 229 234; 523 220 222; 524 222 224; 525 220 224; 526 225 223;
527 225 221; 528 221 223; 529 228 227; 530 228 226; 531 226 227; 532 231 230;
533 231 229; 534 229 230; 535 234 233; 536 234 232; 537 232 233; 538 233 235;
539 233 230; 540 230 227; 541 227 223; 542 223 224; 543 224 217; 544 234 236;
545 234 231; 546 231 228; 547 228 225; 548 225 220; 549 220 218; 550 232 237;
551 232 229; 552 229 226; 553 226 221; 554 221 222; 555 222 219; 556 238 239;
557 240 241; 558 242 243; 559 241 244; 560 243 245; 561 239 246; 562 246 247;
563 244 248; 564 245 249; 565 248 250; 566 249 251; 567 247 252; 568 238 240;
569 240 242; 570 238 242; 571 243 241; 572 243 239; 573 239 241; 574 246 245;
575 246 244; 576 244 245; 577 249 248; 578 249 247; 579 247 248; 580 252 251;
581 252 250; 582 250 251; 583 251 253; 584 251 248; 585 248 245; 586 245 241;
587 241 242; 588 242 235; 589 252 254; 590 252 249; 591 249 246; 592 246 243;
593 243 238; 594 238 236; 595 250 255; 596 250 247; 597 247 244; 598 244 239;
599 239 240; 600 240 237; 601 256 257; 602 258 259; 603 260 261; 604 259 262;
605 261 263; 606 257 264; 607 264 265; 608 262 266; 609 263 267; 610 266 268;
611 267 269; 612 265 270; 613 256 258; 614 258 260; 615 256 260; 616 261 259;
617 261 257; 618 257 259; 619 264 263; 620 264 262; 621 262 263; 622 267 266;
623 267 265; 624 265 266; 625 270 269; 626 270 268; 627 268 269; 628 269 271;
629 269 266; 630 266 263; 631 263 259; 632 259 260; 633 260 253; 634 270 272;
635 270 267; 636 267 264; 637 264 261; 638 261 256; 639 256 254; 640 268 273;
641 268 265; 642 265 262; 643 262 257; 644 257 258; 645 258 255; 646 274 275;
647 276 277; 648 278 279; 649 277 280; 650 279 281; 651 275 282; 652 282 283;
653 280 284; 654 281 285; 655 284 286; 656 285 287; 657 283 288; 658 274 276;
659 276 278; 660 274 278; 661 279 277; 662 279 275; 663 275 277; 664 282 281;
665 282 280; 666 280 281; 667 285 284; 668 285 283; 669 283 284; 670 288 287;
671 288 286; 672 286 287; 673 287 289; 674 287 284; 675 284 281; 676 281 277;
677 277 278; 678 278 271; 679 288 290; 680 288 285; 681 285 282; 682 282 279;
683 279 274; 684 274 272; 685 286 291; 686 286 283; 687 283 280; 688 280 275;
689 275 276; 690 276 273; 691 292 293; 692 294 295; 693 296 297; 694 295 298;
695 297 299; 696 293 300; 697 300 301; 698 298 302; 699 299 303; 700 302 304;
701 303 305; 702 301 306; 703 292 294; 704 294 296; 705 292 296; 706 297 295;
707 297 293; 708 293 295; 709 300 299; 710 300 298; 711 298 299; 712 303 302;
713 303 301; 714 301 302; 715 306 305; 716 306 304; 717 304 305; 718 305 21;
719 305 302; 720 302 299; 721 299 295; 722 295 296; 723 296 289; 724 306 5;
725 306 303; 726 303 300; 727 300 297; 728 297 292; 729 292 290; 730 304 13;
731 304 301; 732 301 298; 733 298 293; 734 293 294; 735 294 291; 736 307 308;
737 309 310; 738 311 312; 739 310 313; 740 312 314; 741 308 315; 742 315 316;
743 313 317; 744 314 318; 745 317 319; 746 318 320; 747 316 321; 748 307 309;
749 309 311; 750 307 311; 751 312 310; 752 312 308; 753 308 310; 754 315 314;
755 315 313; 756 313 314; 757 318 317; 758 318 316; 759 316 317; 760 321 320;
761 321 319; 762 319 320; 763 320 322; 764 320 317; 765 317 314; 766 314 310;
767 310 311; 768 311 21; 769 321 323; 770 321 318; 771 318 315; 772 315 312;
773 312 307; 774 307 5; 775 319 324; 776 319 316; 777 316 313; 778 313 308;
779 308 309; 780 309 13; 781 325 326; 782 327 328; 783 329 330; 784 328 331;
785 330 332; 786 326 333; 787 333 334; 788 331 335; 789 332 336; 790 335 337;
791 336 338; 792 334 339; 793 325 327; 794 327 329; 795 325 329; 796 330 328;
797 330 326; 798 326 328; 799 333 332; 800 333 331; 801 331 332; 802 336 335;
803 336 334; 804 334 335; 805 339 338; 806 339 337; 807 337 338; 808 338 340;
809 338 335; 810 335 332; 811 332 328; 812 328 329; 813 329 322; 814 339 341;
815 339 336; 816 336 333; 817 333 330; 818 330 325; 819 325 323; 820 337 342;
821 337 334; 822 334 331; 823 331 326; 824 326 327; 825 327 324; 826 343 344;
827 345 346; 828 347 348; 829 346 349; 830 348 350; 831 344 351; 832 351 352;
833 349 353; 834 350 354; 835 353 355; 836 354 356; 837 352 357; 838 343 345;
839 345 347; 840 343 347; 841 348 346; 842 348 344; 843 344 346; 844 351 350;
845 351 349; 846 349 350; 847 354 353; 848 354 352; 849 352 353; 850 357 356;
851 357 355; 852 355 356; 853 356 358; 854 356 353; 855 353 350; 856 350 346;
857 346 347; 858 347 340; 859 357 359; 860 357 354; 861 354 351; 862 351 348;
863 348 343; 864 343 341; 865 355 360; 866 355 352; 867 352 349; 868 349 344;
869 344 345; 870 345 342; 871 361 362; 872 363 364; 873 365 366; 874 364 367;
875 366 368; 876 362 369; 877 369 370; 878 367 371; 879 368 372; 880 371 373;
881 372 374; 882 370 375; 883 361 363; 884 363 365; 885 361 365; 886 366 364;
887 366 362; 888 362 364; 889 369 368; 890 369 367; 891 367 368; 892 372 371;
893 372 370; 894 370 371; 895 375 374; 896 375 373; 897 373 374; 898 374 376;
899 374 371; 900 371 368; 901 368 364; 902 364 365; 903 365 358; 904 375 377;
905 375 372; 906 372 369; 907 369 366; 908 366 361; 909 361 359; 910 373 378;
911 373 370; 912 370 367; 913 367 362; 914 362 363; 915 363 360; 916 379 380;
917 381 382; 918 383 384; 919 382 385; 920 384 386; 921 380 387; 922 387 388;
923 385 389; 924 386 390; 925 389 391; 926 390 392; 927 388 393; 928 379 381;
929 381 383; 930 379 383; 931 384 382; 932 384 380; 933 380 382; 934 387 386;
935 387 385; 936 385 386; 937 390 389; 938 390 388; 939 388 389; 940 393 392;
941 393 391; 942 391 392; 943 392 22; 944 392 389; 945 389 386; 946 386 382;
947 382 383; 948 383 376; 949 393 6; 950 393 390; 951 390 387; 952 387 384;
953 384 379; 954 379 377; 955 391 14; 956 391 388; 957 388 385; 958 385 380;
959 380 381; 960 381 378; 961 394 395; 962 396 397; 963 398 399; 964 397 400;
965 399 401; 966 395 402; 967 402 403; 968 400 404; 969 401 405; 970 404 406;
971 405 407; 972 403 408; 973 394 396; 974 396 398; 975 394 398; 976 399 397;
977 399 395; 978 395 397; 979 402 401; 980 402 400; 981 400 401; 982 405 404;
983 405 403; 984 403 404; 985 408 407; 986 408 406; 987 406 407; 988 407 409;
989 407 404; 990 404 401; 991 401 397; 992 397 398; 993 398 22; 994 408 410;
995 408 405; 996 405 402; 997 402 399; 998 399 394; 999 394 6; 1000 406 411;
1001 406 403; 1002 403 400; 1003 400 395; 1004 395 396; 1005 396 14;
1006 412 413; 1007 414 415; 1008 416 417; 1009 415 418; 1010 417 419;
1011 413 420; 1012 420 421; 1013 418 422; 1014 419 423; 1015 422 424;
1016 423 425; 1017 421 426; 1018 412 414; 1019 414 416; 1020 412 416;
1021 417 415; 1022 417 413; 1023 413 415; 1024 420 419; 1025 420 418;
1026 418 419; 1027 423 422; 1028 423 421; 1029 421 422; 1030 426 425;
1031 426 424; 1032 424 425; 1033 425 427; 1034 425 422; 1035 422 419;
1036 419 415; 1037 415 416; 1038 416 409; 1039 426 428; 1040 426 423;
1041 423 420; 1042 420 417; 1043 417 412; 1044 412 410; 1045 424 429;
1046 424 421; 1047 421 418; 1048 418 413; 1049 413 414; 1050 414 411;
1051 430 431; 1052 432 433; 1053 434 435; 1054 433 436; 1055 435 437;
1056 431 438; 1057 438 439; 1058 436 440; 1059 437 441; 1060 440 442;
1061 441 443; 1062 439 444; 1063 430 432; 1064 432 434; 1065 430 434;
1066 435 433; 1067 435 431; 1068 431 433; 1069 438 437; 1070 438 436;
1071 436 437; 1072 441 440; 1073 441 439; 1074 439 440; 1075 444 443;
1076 444 442; 1077 442 443; 1078 443 445; 1079 443 440; 1080 440 437;
1081 437 433; 1082 433 434; 1083 434 427; 1084 444 446; 1085 444 441;
1086 441 438; 1087 438 435; 1088 435 430; 1089 430 428; 1090 442 447;
1091 442 439; 1092 439 436; 1093 436 431; 1094 431 432; 1095 432 429;
1096 448 449; 1097 450 451; 1098 452 453; 1099 451 454; 1100 453 455;
1101 449 456; 1102 456 457; 1103 454 458; 1104 455 459; 1105 458 460;
1106 459 461; 1107 457 462; 1108 448 450; 1109 450 452; 1110 448 452;
1111 453 451; 1112 453 449; 1113 449 451; 1114 456 455; 1115 456 454;
1116 454 455; 1117 459 458; 1118 459 457; 1119 457 458; 1120 462 461;
1121 462 460; 1122 460 461; 1123 461 463; 1124 461 458; 1125 458 455;
1126 455 451; 1127 451 452; 1128 452 445; 1129 462 464; 1130 462 459;
1131 459 456; 1132 456 453; 1133 453 448; 1134 448 446; 1135 460 465;
1136 460 457; 1137 457 454; 1138 454 449; 1139 449 450; 1140 450 447;
1141 466 467; 1142 468 469; 1143 470 471; 1144 469 472; 1145 471 473;
1146 467 474; 1147 474 475; 1148 472 476; 1149 473 477; 1150 476 478;
1151 477 479; 1152 475 480; 1153 466 468; 1154 468 470; 1155 466 470;
1156 471 469; 1157 471 467; 1158 467 469; 1159 474 473; 1160 474 472;
1161 472 473; 1162 477 476; 1163 477 475; 1164 475 476; 1165 480 479;
1166 480 478; 1167 478 479; 1168 479 481; 1169 479 476; 1170 476 473;
1171 473 469; 1172 469 470; 1173 470 463; 1174 480 482; 1175 480 477;
1176 477 474; 1177 474 471; 1178 471 466; 1179 466 464; 1180 478 483;
1181 478 475; 1182 475 472; 1183 472 467; 1184 467 468; 1185 468 465;
1186 484 485; 1187 486 487; 1188 488 489; 1189 487 490; 1190 489 491;
1191 485 492; 1192 8 492; 1193 492 489; 1194 489 484; 1195 484 482;
1196 24 491; 1197 491 487; 1198 487 488; 1199 488 481; 1200 16 490;
1201 490 485; 1202 485 486; 1203 486 483; 1204 491 490; 1205 490 492;
1206 492 491; 1207 487 485; 1208 485 489; 1209 489 487; 1210 488 486;
1211 486 484; 1212 484 488;
START GROUP DEFINITION
MEMBER
_PL1 43 TO 60 88 TO 105 133 TO 150 178 TO 195 223 TO 240 273 278 279 285
_PL2 223 229 230 235 268 TO 285 313 TO 330 358 TO 375 403 TO 420 448 TO 465 -
498 504 510
_PL3 448 454 460 493 TO 510 538 TO 555 583 TO 600 628 TO 645 673 TO 690 718 -
719 TO 735 768 774 780
_PL4 718 724 730 763 TO 780 808 TO 825 853 TO 870 898 TO 915 943 TO 960 993 -
999 1005
_PL5 943 949 955 988 TO 1005 1033 TO 1050 1078 TO 1095 1123 TO 1140 -
1168 TO 1185 1192 TO 1203
_PL6 43 TO 60 88 TO 105 136 TO 138 142 TO 144 148 TO 150
_PL7 133 TO 135 139 TO 141 145 TO 147 178 TO 195 223 TO 240 268 TO 285 313 -
314 TO 330 361 TO 363 367 TO 369 373 TO 375
_PL8 358 TO 360 364 TO 366 370 TO 372 403 TO 420 448 TO 465 493 TO 510 538 -
539 TO 555 583 TO 600 633 639 645
_PL9 628 TO 645 673 TO 690 718 TO 735 763 TO 780 808 TO 825 856 TO 858 862 -
863 TO 864 868 TO 870
_PL10 853 TO 855 859 TO 861 865 TO 867 898 TO 915 943 TO 960 988 TO 1005 1033 -
1034 TO 1050 1078 TO 1095 1128 1134 1140
_PL11 1078 1084 1090 1123 TO 1140 1168 TO 1185 1192 TO 1203
END GROUP DEFINITION
DEFINE MATERIAL START
ISOTROPIC STEEL
E 2.05e+008
POISSON 0.3
DENSITY 76.8195
ALPHA 1.2e-005
DAMP 0.03
TYPE STEEL
STRENGTH FY 253200 FU 407800 RY 1.5 RT 1.2
ISOTROPIC CONCRETE
E 2.17185e+007
POISSON 0.17
DENSITY 23.5616
ALPHA 1e-005
DAMP 0.05
TYPE CONCRETE
STRENGTH FCU 27579
END DEFINE MATERIAL
MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
43 TO 60 88 TO 105 133 TO 150 178 TO 195 223 TO 240 268 TO 285 313 TO 330 -
358 TO 375 403 TO 420 448 TO 465 493 TO 510 538 TO 555 583 TO 600 -
628 TO 645 673 TO 690 718 TO 735 763 TO 780 808 TO 825 853 TO 870 -
898 TO 915 943 TO 960 988 TO 1005 1033 TO 1050 1078 TO 1095 1123 TO 1140 -
1168 TO 1185 1192 TO 1203 PRIS YD 0.07
16 TO 42 61 TO 87 106 TO 132 151 TO 177 196 TO 222 241 TO 267 286 TO 312 331 -
332 TO 357 376 TO 402 421 TO 447 466 TO 492 511 TO 537 556 TO 582 601 TO 627 -
646 TO 672 691 TO 717 736 TO 762 781 TO 807 826 TO 852 871 TO 897 -
916 TO 942 961 TO 987 1006 TO 1032 1051 TO 1077 1096 TO 1122 1141 TO 1167 -
1186 TO 1191 1204 TO 1212 PRIS ROUND STA 0.0424 END 0.0424 THI 0.004
1 TO 3 6 TO 8 11 TO 13 PRIS YD 0.03
4 5 9 10 14 15 PRIS YD 0.034
CONSTANTS
MATERIAL STEEL ALL
SUPPORTS
1 4 7 9 12 15 17 20 23 FIXED
41 43 45 PINNED
MEMBER CABLE
1 TO 15 TENSION 55
LOAD 1 LOADTYPE Dead TITLE SELFWEIGHT
SELFWEIGHT Y -1
JOINT LOAD
301 TO 303 388 TO 390 485 487 489 FY -0.2
304 TO 306 391 TO 393 490 TO 492 FY -0.4
PERFORM CABLE ANALYSIS BASIC STEPS 10 EQITERATIONS 100
CHANGE
LOAD 5 LOADTYPE Ice TITLE ICE
SELFWEIGHT Y -1
JOINT LOAD
301 TO 303 388 TO 390 485 487 489 FY -3
304 TO 306 391 TO 393 490 TO 492 FY -3
MEMBER LOAD
43 TO 60 88 TO 105 133 TO 150 178 TO 195 223 TO 240 268 TO 285 313 TO 330 -
358 TO 375 403 TO 420 448 TO 465 493 TO 510 538 TO 555 583 TO 600 -
628 TO 645 673 TO 690 718 TO 735 763 TO 780 808 TO 825 853 TO 870 -
898 TO 915 943 TO 960 988 TO 1005 1033 TO 1050 1078 TO 1095 1123 TO 1140 -
1168 TO 1185 1192 TO 1203 UNI GY -0.296
PERFORM CABLE ANALYSIS BASIC STEPS 10 EQITERATIONS 100 SAGMINIMUM 0.9
CHANGE
LOAD 6 LOADTYPE Wind on Ice TITLE WIND ON ICE - 0 DEG
SELFWEIGHT Y -1
MEMBER LOAD
43 TO 60 88 TO 105 133 TO 150 178 TO 195 223 TO 240 273 278 279 -
285 UNI GZ 0.352
223 229 230 235 268 TO 285 313 TO 330 358 TO 375 403 TO 420 448 TO 465 498 -
504 510 UNI GZ 0.42
448 454 460 493 TO 510 538 TO 555 583 TO 600 628 TO 645 673 TO 690 -
718 TO 735 768 774 780 UNI GZ 0.469
718 724 730 763 TO 780 808 TO 825 853 TO 870 898 TO 915 943 TO 960 993 999 -
1005 UNI GZ 0.499
943 949 955 988 TO 1005 1033 TO 1050 1078 TO 1095 1123 TO 1140 1168 TO 1185 -
1192 TO 1203 UNI GZ 0.525
1 TO 15 UNI GZ 0.24
PERFORM CABLE ANALYSIS BASIC STEPS 10 EQITERATIONS 100 SAGMINIMUM 0.9
CHANGE
LOAD 302 G + MWI(0) + ICE
REPEAT LOAD
1 1.0 5 0.6 6 0.78
PERFORM CABLE ANALYSIS BASIC STEPS 10 EQITERATIONS 100 SAGMINIMUM 0.9
FINISH.
communities.bentley.com/.../Mast_5F00_D.std
I have pretension of all cables with 55kN but when I run analysis for only Selfweight (LC1) I get only 10kN in longest (highest) cables. It seems to me very low.
As you can see I was forced to make some specific (not much logical) configurations in order to make analysis be completed without errors:
- Supports of cables are fixed (probably neccesary to restrain torsion);
- PERFORM CABLE ANALYSIS BASIC STEPS 10 EQITERATIONS 100 SAGMINIMUM 0.9;
My question is:
Are results I get with this calculation accurate and reliable? If so, how to explain such a low tension in cables for selfweight?
Thank you very much!
